Who to replace

Go down

Who to replace

Post by Tedage on Thu May 10, 2012 7:59 pm

I still have a fair few original players in my squad who have no place being there anymore, I could use some assistance in weeding out who's worth keeping and who I need to get rid of. Please feel free to tell me if I'm playing them in the wrong position etc.

Mark "Emergency Use Only" Carey - No idea where he should play if at all
22 y/o (R16, D1) | 21,764 CSR (+214) | $4,979 p.w. | 186cm | 105kg | England
Right handed, right footed, in reputable form .
A collected player with collected discipline, satisfactory leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Perfect 109%
Stamina: Decent Handling: Admirable
Attack: Satisfactory Defense: Satisfactory
Technique: Reputable Strength: Moderate
Jumping: Moderate Speed: Admirable
Agility: Despicable Kicking: Despicable

Pierre-Louis Grageon - Back up 8 purely for physicals
18 y/o (R8, D5) | 13,590 CSR (+103) | $4,090 p.w. | 203cm | 127kg | France
Right handed, right footed, in average form .
An aggressive player with collected discipline, admirable leadership, and non-existent experience.
Energy: Perfect 106%
Stamina: Decent Handling: Satisfactory
Attack: Satisfactory Defense: Satisfactory
Technique: Moderate Strength: Decent
Jumping: Satisfactory Speed: Average
Agility: Moderate Kicking: Despicable

Ryan Titler - Nice bizarre mix of stats
23 y/o (R15, D3) | 25,415 CSR (+237) | $5,557 p.w. | 182cm | 78kg | England
Right handed, right footed, in average form .
An aggressive player with collected discipline, satisfactory leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Supercharged 99%
Stamina: Moderate Handling: Impressive
Attack: Average Defense: Reputable
Technique: Average Strength: Limited
Jumping: Limited Speed: Admirable
Agility: Average Kicking: Admirable

Jorge Thorne - Backup FB
23 y/o (R2, D2) | 18,293 CSR (+152) | $4,685 p.w. | 182cm | 85kg | England
Right handed, left footed, in decent form .
An aggressive player with controlled discipline, non-existent leadership, and limited experience.
Energy: Supercharged 97%
Stamina: Decent Handling: Average
Attack: Decent Defense: Admirable
Technique: Horrible Strength: Moderate
Jumping: Horrible Speed: Satisfactory
Agility: Reputable Kicking: Average

Renaud Olivier - Backup Flanker
18 y/o (R9, D1) | 20,658 CSR (+151) | $5,516 p.w. | 192cm | 110kg | France
Right handed, right footed, in average form .
An aggressive player with collected discipline, moderate leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Supercharged 96%
Stamina: Decent Handling: Decent
Attack: Satisfactory Defense: Admirable
Technique: Reputable Strength: Reputable
Jumping: Average Speed: Moderate
Agility: Satisfactory Kicking: Moderate

Brent Boatwright - Backup prop for physicals again
20 y/o (R1, D4) | 13,240 CSR (+133) | $3,544 p.w. | 186cm | 131kg | New Zealand
Right handed, right footed, in decent form .
A conservative player with controlled discipline, moderate leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Pumped 82%
Stamina: Admirable Handling: Satisfactory
Attack: Moderate Defense: Satisfactory
Technique: Satisfactory Strength: Satisfactory
Jumping: Despicable Speed: Moderate
Agility: Horrible Kicking: Despicable

Lance Grieve - Current FB
25 y/o (R3, D6) | 27,225 CSR (+248) | $5,521 p.w. | 174cm | 89kg | England
Right handed, right footed, in satisfactory form .
An aggressive player with controlled discipline, decent leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Sprightly 63%
Stamina: Princely Handling: Decent
Attack: Admirable Defense: Admirable
Technique: Horrible Strength: Limited
Jumping: Horrible Speed: Average
Agility: Decent Kicking: Average

Milton Jeremiah - Current 12
21 y/o (R9, D1) | 21,492 CSR (+177) | $5,128 p.w. | 193cm | 100kg | England
Right handed, right footed, in decent form .
A conservative player with controlled discipline, average leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Pumped 85%
Stamina: Admirable Handling: Satisfactory
Attack: Admirable Defense: Reputable
Technique: Average Strength: Satisfactory
Jumping: Satisfactory Speed: Average
Agility: Moderate Kicking: Non-Existent

Ramiro Gorosito - Backup Centre
18 y/o (R3, D2) | 19,119 CSR (+125) | $5,103 p.w. | 189cm | 111kg | Argentina
Right handed, right footed, in satisfactory form .
An aggressive player with controlled discipline, average leadership, and despicable experience.
Energy: Energised 71%
Stamina: Satisfactory Handling: Satisfactory
Attack: Reputable Defense: Reputable
Technique: Average Strength: Reputable
Jumping: Decent Speed: Moderate
Agility: Average Kicking: Horrible

Thanks in advance for your words of encouragement...
Much love,
Ted

Tedage

Posts : 239
Join date : 2011-10-12
Age : 34

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Who to replace

Post by Tedage on Thu May 10, 2012 8:04 pm

I have a decent backup Hooker, Lock, Flanker and Wing btw

Tedage

Posts : 239
Join date : 2011-10-12
Age : 34

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Who to replace

Post by jeolmaga on Fri May 11, 2012 12:36 am

Mark and ryan could play on the wings. Ryan isnt so bizarre actually he looks alright to play on the wing with the speed he has
avatar
jeolmaga

Posts : 183
Join date : 2011-10-17

View user profile

Back to top Go down

My stab at it

Post by Mega man al on Fri May 11, 2012 11:51 am

This is a best guess advice and you will probably try and seek a more educated answer.

Mark Carey - With his Speed and weight I'd have him as a crash inside centre, draw back being his strength may let him down, he probably is lacking in the agility stakes to be a wing.

Pierre Louis Grageon - Height and weight would make him a good lock and if I had him at 17 I might of trained him up to some standard, but in all honesty you could probably buy 17 year olds who are a bit taller with the same CSR for cheap and work on them but either way 203cm isn't bad for a lock especially with is weight in the scrum

Ryan Titler - Good Handling, speed, agility and kicking small with low weight I would say your typical srum half I would have him as. His attack could be better but always think you'd want a No.9 with okay kicking for those box kicks.

Jorge Thorne - Good defence for a FB but with no other noticeable stats, his low CSR and age I really wouldn't see why you'd keep him, despite his low weight you'd be better off having Titler as your back up FB

Renaud Olivier - Flanker is bang on really this and if you haven't got a better back up then keep around

Brent Boatwright - He's not amazing true but if he's the only Back Up you've got the fact he adds 131kg to the scrum is never going to be a bad thing, yet again with his age and low CSR he's never going to develop into anything great.

Lance Grieve - Honestly I would consider changing your FB to Ryan Titler but some people may beg to differ with me on this. Fair enough his Attack is better but with Titler's superior speed, agility kicking and handling I'd want some one who was more guaranteed to catch the ball and give it a good hoof if needed.

Milton Jeremiah - Fine as a centre speed could be a little better but between himself and Mark Carey I would go for his better Attack and Defence over Carey

Ramiro Gorosito - With low speed but better attack and defence so I would have used him as a back up flanker as opposed to a back up centre.

So with all that gubbins this really depends on to your funds to invest in new players and what you need. But just on my view without all the knowledge.

Carey - Backup centre CSR is growing an an okay rate so maybe hold on to see if attack or defence pops

Grageon - Low CSR and low increase a week I would say, despite physicals you have to ask yourself is he worth the £4,090 he's costing you a week and if you could get something better for £4000 a week

Titler - Really would keep and try at FB (but I open to anyone mocking this suggestion).

Thorne - With his age and lowish CSR I would yet again ask if he is worth the £4,600 a week, especially if your going to put in Titler for FB trials.

Olivier - Better defence than Gorosito I would keep as your back up flanker

Boatwright - He has good physicals true but like with Grageon if you could find better stats for £3,500 to £4,000 a week you may be better off.

Grieve - Maybe move to back up FB is Titler becomes the better option not sure what your 13 is like but maybe worth a look

Jeremiah - Keep at 12

Gorosito - Flanker or Centre I think you have better options for both so I would sell and save yourself the weekly wage

Like I said someone more educated may give you better help but hopefully I may have given you something to think about

Stay Mega



avatar
Mega man al

Posts : 76
Join date : 2012-05-03
Age : 34
Location : Cornwall

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Who to replace

Post by Tedage on Fri May 11, 2012 12:26 pm

Thanks for the input Mega!

Tedage

Posts : 239
Join date : 2011-10-12
Age : 34

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Who to replace

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum